I want to create a game and I woul like some recommendations

[Pokoro5]

I been playing this kinda of games for a few years and I noticed that recently all the games are mostly the same ( history, female models and concept) so I want to spice thing up creating something more unique, the are two things that I would not change for the money and time that I already spent on them so It's gonna be a 2d game and it's gonna be made in rpgmaker I have some ideas wich I'll post in this thread if you are interested.
But any ideas or suggestions about anything ( history, characters, gameplay) I would be delighted to hear about it

 

[Pokoro5]

In terms of history I have some ideas
1. You trying to win your girls over the antagonist ( an old man, criminal organization, a bullying, etc) it something that we have been seeing but almost no game has ever been completed.
2. You are the bad guy and your mission it's to defeat the hero and while you do that you get some girls.
3. From good guy to bad a tale of good person that for some reason ( betrayal, power, lust) start to loose the path of righteous and becomes evil.
4. Any of your recommendations

 

[Pokoro5]

In terms of girls I belive 7 it's the magic number, by my experience to much makes the game too long for no reason some characters have a ton of history and personality while others well they are more like a potato that you can fuck.
Roles: I feel like there are some that are to used (teacher, boss, cheerleader)
So I thoug of less used would be better but I want to hear your opinion

 

[Pokoro5]

There are more things that we can talk about like who is the mc or in what place the history start but I let you talk about this yourselves, what I want to talk it's the most important part the time I don't want to milk this game so I'm gonna be very upfront with you if this post starts to get a lot of love I would start to work right away first creating a discord we're I would be updating you all completely free of all my steps and when I have at least 20% of the game complete I would start to post the game once I did that the game would be finished in a term of 12-18 months. I would also create a patreon or whatever for everyone that wants to support me, but that is less important so that's pretty much it. If I receive no reply or almost no interest I would start more slowly and train to get more attention before publishing the first update, thank you for your attention

 

[RLRS]

In the case of characters, try to include a diversity of ethnicities, but without needing to exaggerate the number of female characters. (Depending on the plot and whether you are going to have the harem tag or not, at least 5 or 6 is enough if you know how to work well, if you are going to implement more you have to start being careful with the plot, so that the game does not become confused).

The characters having a sexy body without having to exaggerate the proportions is also enough.

And do you have any ideas about the game's setting (medieval, futuristic, retrofuturistic, etc.)?

 

[RLRS]

In terms of history I have some ideas
1. You trying to win your girls over the antagonist ( an old man, criminal organization, a bullying, etc) it something that we have been seeing but almost no game has ever been completed.
2. You are the bad guy and your mission it's to defeat the hero and while you do that you get some girls.
3. From good guy to bad a tale of good person that for some reason ( betrayal, power, lust) start to loose the path of righteous and becomes evil.
4. Any of your recommendations

The plot idea I was going to suggest is totally different from what you said.

bodyguard plot:

The plot idea I was going to suggest would be a game with a similar setting to a game that was abandoned called "Bodyguard of Lust", I know there is a game in development with a similar plot called "Midnight Sin" which in my opinion is also very good , I know it's in unity and the graphics are very different from Bodyguard of lust.
But since you want to make the game in RPG Maker, the Bodyguard of Lust storyline would be an idea I would suggest to you.

 

[Pokoro5]

The plot idea I was going to suggest is totally different from what you said.

bodyguard plot:

The plot idea I was going to suggest would be a game with a similar setting to a game that was abandoned called "Bodyguard of Lust", I know there is a game in development with a similar plot called "Midnight Sin" which in my opinion is also very good , I know it's in unity and the graphics are very different from Bodyguard of lust.
But since you want to make the game in RPG Maker, the Bodyguard of Lust storyline would be an idea I would suggest to you.

I have not played those game but reading the overview i guess its similar to other games that I have played were you are a body guard we're you have to protec the girls of the house and you get to know them than fuck them that could be interesting

 

[RLRS]

I have not played those game but reading the overview i guess its similar to other games that I have played were you are a body guard we're you have to protec the girls of the house and you get to know them than fuck them that could be interesting

Since you think it might be interesting and plan to do it in RPG Maker, at least try Bodyguard of Lust to get some ideas, but if you think it's interesting to try Midnight Sin, I also recommend it (but remember this is in Unity) .

 

[Pokoro5]

In the case of characters, try to include a diversity of ethnicities, but without needing to exaggerate the number of female characters. (Depending on the plot and whether you are going to have the harem tag or not, at least 5 or 6 is enough if you know how to work well, if you are going to implement more you have to start being careful with the plot, so that the game does not become confused).

The characters having a sexy body without having to exaggerate the proportions is also enough.

And do you have any ideas about the game's setting (medieval, futuristic, retrofuturistic, etc.)?

Yes these are some amazing question
1. You are right putting to much girls would be hard at the moment of writing my number was 7 but it totally can go from 5-8 depending on the story.
2. Yes I feel that different ethnicitys and body types would make every character different and especial I love white brunette women but in almost all the games they are the majority and I want to make it more balanced. (And I don't plant to put women with overly exaggerated proportion unless everyone ask me to)
3. And lastly the game settings I have some options
One in 1900 but with a fantasy world.
The second it's in the Roman empire (this could be a little more difficult to pull it off).
An lastly in a poor island we're almost nobody lives there
But I'm open to other ideas

 

[Pokoro5]

Since you think it might be interesting and plan to do it in RPG Maker, at least try Bodyguard of Lust to get some ideas, but if you think it's interesting to try Midnight Sin, I also recommend it (but remember this is in Unity) .

Yes I would definitely try and see if it's plausible to be created in rpgmaker while no lossing the essence

 

[RLRS]

Yes I would definitely try and see if it's plausible to be created in rpgmaker while no lossing the essence

I see, I'm talking about these games so that you also have an idea of the settings (locations), possible tasks (types of tasks), roles of the characters (housewife, any daughter or daughters, maid, driver, if the MC already has some connection with a character or discovers during the plot, etc.).

 

[ps5029]

I think it would be good to talk about a drab big city slum in the western United States in the early 1900s.
The main character is a private investigator, and during the investigation, he meets a grieving widow and attractive women and develops relationships with them.

In the process, the player may be exposed to a hotbed of criminal organizations and a corrupt society and become corrupted, or he may be bribed by a corporation or a wealthy person and gradually change into a bad person.
Or, it would be nice if he could remain a heroic and great detective until the end.

If you want to add fantasy, you could add a little magic to bring some drama to the dull atmosphere. Or, you can add a different race to increase character diversity.

 

[Mr. Cofman]

I will give you unrequired opinion.
Don't make something very unique, it will only scare people.
Why? Fear of unknown.

I can give a few examples that being influenced by something may not only be successful but fun.
Black Souls - a collaboration of fairy tales, later lovecraftian things and many other. If it had no porn with child looking characters, it surely would be more popular than it is, so people with no morals love it, to the point of obsession. Hihihi~
Abaddon: Princess of the Decay - you can tell how much that game is influenced by

You must be registered to see the links

. And yet it is quite successful, even more than Black Souls if I'm not wrong.
Hmm... there are also a few examples shared by ChatGPT, look:

• Spoiler: Other examples

  You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

That's why I don't think you need to make something very unique.

 

[RLRS]

Note: Just a reminder that I'm just trying to help you decide on tags, I'm not saying what's right or wrong, nor criticizing varying tastes for any fetishes.

Another point that was not talked about or was forgotten is about tags.

basic rule: no need to fill the game with
several tags (several fetishes at once), and on some specific tags, I recommend that you only work if you are sure of that particular tag and/or have had it in your plans since the beginning of game planning.

For example: NTR divides people a lot, if you don't have any plan and you also don't want to have avoidable NTR then don't even think about adding him so as not to hinder development.
Harem: I already talked a little about this in one of the first messages here.
Voyeurism: at most a few scenes with the MC imagining him having relationships with certain characters, so people don't complain: "where are the real scenes", "when are there going to be sexual scenes between the characters",
“Will this remain only in the imagination?!”



Are you almost sure you will use these tags?:

2d/2dcg
big boobs
big ass
interracial
male protagonist
milf (mature mother)
adolescent
oral sex
vaginal sex
anal sex

possible tags:
harem, incest(depending on the plot).

And don't forget to tell us if you've already decided on the subject, to be even more sure about the tags.

============================================================================

Here are some very optional items I mentioned as an example that aren't necessarily worth considering unless they're in your plans:
other possible tags:
other tags depending on the plot (depending on the game) and familiarity with the theme (example: sandbox, ntr (avoidable or not), bdsm, voyeurism, etc).

 

[Pokoro5]

Man I love that you'll have been given some really good advice and I have been trying to mix all together while maintaining a good story so based on your recommendations I think that a mix between you all recommendations: so this is my idea
1.You were either born o wash on the shore in a small island (it would depend if you want incest or not), you live with 2 beautiful milfs( I think about making them twins)
2.In this small island there are 3 or 4 village depending on how hard it's to create a whole village that looks lively, thus village are part of a corrupt government but they don't care much about it because they believe that the island has not natural resources, and for that reason is kinda disconnected from the rest of the world
3.the time that is base in 1900 so electricity and firearms in other things are a thing but you almost never seen it, because you live in this disconnected island.
4. The plot starts when the monsters atack your village. After that a bunch of people either died or flew to another place. You being one of the few men that still are in the village you were given the tittle of the Hunter given to you by the new mayor, and with that title now you have to hunt monsters and protect the village while investigating why now a a bunch of monster are attacking your village it's some kinda of conspiracy, I also plain to put references or parodys to other game or series so that people get more familiarized with this new game.
That's my idea for now if you have any suggestions let me know and thanks for the feedback.
A one more thing maybe the title it's gonna be the hunter but it feels not creative

 

[ps5029]

I don't know if I understand it well, but it seems to be an almost realistic world view, except for the monsters that appear.
Is this worldview similar to reality, so there is no magic or different races?

If so, I think some steampunk-like tools and a crude crossbow and great sword from the Middle Ages would enhance the atmosphere.

Looking at the items presented, the atmosphere of the Cthulhu Mythos and Fallout series came to mind first.

On the other hand, in order to hunt monsters (or their large, evolved bosses), I wonder what it would be like to investigate monsters and hunt using the characteristics and weaknesses of each monster. Kind of like Monster Hunter?


I wish you could explain a little more clearly what exactly you are drawing.
Then maybe there will be an idea that gets closer to the essence of what you want.

 

[RLRS]

Man I love that you'll have been given some really good advice and I have been trying to mix all together while maintaining a good story so based on your recommendations I think that a mix between you all recommendations: so this is my idea
1.You were either born o wash on the shore in a small island (it would depend if you want incest or not), you live with 2 beautiful milfs( I think about making them twins)
2.In this small island there are 3 or 4 village depending on how hard it's to create a whole village that looks lively, thus village are part of a corrupt government but they don't care much about it because they believe that the island has not natural resources, and for that reason is kinda disconnected from the rest of the world
3.the time that is base in 1900 so electricity and firearms in other things are a thing but you almost never seen it, because you live in this disconnected island.
4. The plot starts when the monsters atack your village. After that a bunch of people either died or flew to another place. You being one of the few men that still are in the village you were given the tittle of the Hunter given to you by the new mayor, and with that title now you have to hunt monsters and protect the village while investigating why now a a bunch of monster are attacking your village it's some kinda of conspiracy, I also plain to put references or parodys to other game or series so that people get more familiarized with this new game.
That's my idea for now if you have any suggestions let me know and thanks for the feedback.
A one more thing maybe the title it's gonna be the hunter but it feels not creative

In the case of monsters, I was also a little confused about how they would be approached.

because as you said you want to involve investigation, and you said the following sentence: "You, being one of the few men left in the village, received the title of Hunter given to you by the new mayor, and with that title you now hunt monsters and protect the village while investigating why now a bunch of monsters are attacking their village is some kind of conspiracy."


So could it be that at some point in the plot the MC discovers that the monsters are actually humans undergoing experiments and this gives a twist to the game's story?

And would the hunting part be just to gain experience (XP)? or how would this be approached?

 

[Cartman-Brah]

2. You are the bad guy and your mission it's to defeat the hero and while you do that you get some girls.

an evil mc sounds cool. there are very few games like that. the ones that exist are usually motivated by raping people. if you can create a bad guy with a really brilliant idea, you'll get attention.

 

[Pokoro5]

I don't know if I understand it well, but it seems to be an almost realistic world view, except for the monsters that appear.
Is this worldview similar to reality, so there is no magic or different races?

If so, I think some steampunk-like tools and a crude crossbow and great sword from the Middle Ages would enhance the atmosphere.

Looking at the items presented, the atmosphere of the Cthulhu Mythos and Fallout series came to mind first.

On the other hand, in order to hunt monsters (or their large, evolved bosses), I wonder what it would be like to investigate monsters and hunt using the characteristics and weaknesses of each monster. Kind of like Monster Hunter?


I wish you could explain a little more clearly what exactly you are drawing.
Then maybe there will be an idea that gets closer to the essence of what you want.

My bad sometimes I have to much ideas and it's hard to landing them.
Im gonna try to answer your doubts It's gonna be a mix of magic and technology, so yes the monster are not mutations but are part of the wildlife of the island, about what you say in weakness I been thinking of a weapon that you can put a orb that modify your stats and some monsters are easy to kill with certain mobs (For example a mob that has a lot of attack but no hp, so you use a orb that makes you attack faster) but the idea of investigate the weakness of each monster also sounds fun

 

[Pokoro5]

In the case of monsters, I was also a little confused about how they would be approached.

because as you said you want to involve investigation, and you said the following sentence: "You, being one of the few men left in the village, received the title of Hunter given to you by the new mayor, and with that title you now hunt monsters and protect the village while investigating why now a bunch of monsters are attacking their village is some kind of conspiracy."


So could it be that at some point in the plot the MC discovers that the monsters are actually humans undergoing experiments and this gives a twist to the game's story?

And would the hunting part be just to gain experience (XP)? or how would this be approached?

My bad about the confusion I'm gonna explain.
Yes the mystery it's gonna revolve around the monster and the island, I don't want to spoil anything but I don't think it's gonna have mutation of humans but the idea it's amazing so you never know.
Killing monsters It's gonna be part of your task, it would be also to level up and gain items to become stronger and to continue the history and get some other rewards ( images, parts of history of the island) I also want to create traps so that the grinding it's not so annoying but I have no idea how to do it (so no promises) I hope that answers some of your questions